Although there are many forms of societies in the world but let’s talk about a comparison between Secularism and Racism as these forms are so much intermingled these days that it has become difficult to understand that particular State like India and Israel is following which form as their societal structure. Let’s take them one by one!
Secularism:
In the opinion of many Secularisms is a principle that
advocates the separation of religion from government and public affairs. It
promotes a neutral stance on matters of religion, ensuring that all citizens,
regardless of their beliefs, are treated equally under the law.
Some of its positive aspects are:
1.
Protects religious freedom by preventing the dominance of any one religion.
2.
Fosters a diverse and inclusive society where people of all faiths and
non-faith can coexist peacefully.
3. Promotes rational decision-making in governance, reducing the potential for religious bias.
While its Con side is reflected in the following ways:
1.
Some argue that secularism can lead to a loss of moral values or a sense of
cultural identity.
2. There can be challenges in defining the boundaries between religion & public life, leading to debates and conflicts.
Racism:
Coming to the racism it
is considered as a belief system or ideology that discriminates against
individuals or groups based on their racial or ethnic background. It involves prejudice, bias, and
discrimination against people of certain races, often leading to unequal
treatment and opportunities.
There are no pros that can be related to racism. It is
widely condemned as harmful and unethical, perpetuating inequality and division
in society. As it leads to social injustice, inequality, and violence. It harms
individuals and communities, hinders social progress, and fosters hatred and
division.
While comparing both we can easily say that Racism and
secularism are fundamentally different concepts. Racism promotes discrimination
based on race, while secularism seeks to ensure a separation of religion from
public affairs. Racism is universally condemned for its harmful effects, while
secularism is a principle embraced in various forms around the world. While Secularism
aims to create a fair and inclusive society, whereas racism perpetuates inequality
and division. In short we can say, racism is a harmful ideology that
discriminates based on race and has no pros. Secularism, on the other hand, is
a principle that advocates the separation of religion from government and
public life, with pros including protection of religious freedom and fostering
a diverse society, but it may also face challenges in implementation.
When it comes to the acceptability, we find out that Secularism is generally more accepted and embraced as a form of governance and ideology in the world compared to racism. Some of the reason in highlighted forms are.
1. Legal Frameworks:
Many countries have secular legal systems or include provisions for religious
freedom and equality in their constitutions. These legal frameworks aim to
protect the rights of individuals regardless of their religious beliefs.
2. Global Consensus:
There is a global consensus against racism. International agreements, such as
the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial
Discrimination, condemn racism and promote equality among races.
3. International
Norms: Secularism aligns with international norms and principles of human
rights. Organizations like the United Nations promote religious freedom and the
separation of religion from the state, which are key components of secularism.
4. Humanitarian
Values: Secularism is often associated with values like freedom, equality,
& tolerance, which are widely seen as positive & desirable. Racism, on
the other hand, is universally condemned for its harmful & divisive
effects.
While secularism is generally more accepted, it's essential
to recognize that the level of acceptance and implementation can vary
significantly from one country to another. Some countries have a strong
commitment to secularism, while others may have more religiously influenced
governance structures. Additionally, efforts to combat racism and promote
equality continue to be essential worldwide.
Secularism
is widely considered better than racism for several compelling reasons:
1. Promotion of Equality
2. Respect for Human Rights
3. Social Harmony
4. Ethical and Moral Values
5. Global Consensus
In conclusion, secularism is considered better than racism
because it upholds principles of equality, human rights, social harmony, and
ethical values. Racism, in contrast, is universally condemned for its harmful
effects on individuals and society. Embracing secularism and rejecting racism
is a step toward creating a more just and inclusive world.
Being a Muslim and representing almost 2 billion Muslims in
the world who follow Islamic Values and form of society we better take a look
as what Islam says about both these forms and which is more acceptable one for
the Muslim to be friends with. Islam,
like many other religions, has a diverse range of interpretations and
perspectives on issues such as racism and secularism. It's important to note
that there is no single, universally accepted stance on these topics within the
Muslim community, as interpretations can vary based on cultural, historical,
and theological factors.
Islam explicitly condemns racism. The Quran emphasizes the
equality of all human beings, stating that "O mankind, indeed We have
created you from male and female and made you peoples and tribes that you may
know one another. Indeed, the most noble of you in the sight of Allah is the
most righteous of you" (Quran, 49:13).
The Prophet Muhammad is reported to have said in his
Farewell Sermon, "All mankind is from Adam and Eve. An Arab has no
superiority over a non-Arab, nor does a non-Arab have any superiority over an
Arab; a white has no superiority over a black, nor does a black have any
superiority over a white; none have superiority over another except by piety
and good action."
However, views on secularism within the Muslim community
vary widely. Some Muslims believe that Islam can coexist with secular
governance and that it is possible to separate religion from politics and state
affairs. Others argue for an Islamic state where Islamic law (Sharia) plays a
central role in governance and public life. While some countries with
Muslim-majority populations have adopted secular or semi-secular systems while
respecting religious freedoms.
Summarizing all, Islam condemns racism and promotes the
equality of all human beings. Views on secularism within Islam vary, and there
is no one-size-fits-all perspective, as interpretations can be influenced by
various factors.
In the end before
closing the whole discussion a question arises in the mind as either Pakistan
is a Secular nation or not and the specific answer to this is No, Pakistan
is not a secular state. Pakistan is officially known as the Islamic Republic of
Pakistan and is an Islamic state. Islam is the state religion, and Islamic
principles influence its legal system and governance. The preamble to
Pakistan's constitution explicitly identifies Islam as the state religion, and
various provisions of the constitution reflect the role of Islamic principles
in the country's legal and political framework.
While Pakistan's constitution does include some provisions
for the protection of religious minorities and their rights, the overall
governance structure of the country is influenced by Islamic principles.
Therefore, Pakistan is commonly categorized as an Islamic state rather than a secular
one.
BY
OVAIS ASAD KAHN